Old coins often look dull, dark or grimy, and the urge to make them shine is natural. If you are asking yourself, “Should I clean old coins?” the answer is almost always no. Cleaning can lower a coin’s value, sometimes a lot. This guide explains why, and how to look after your coins instead.
The short answer
- Please do not clean, polish or scrub old coins.
- Major grading services treat cleaned coins differently, and cleaning usually costs value.
- Hold coins by the edges, over a soft surface, with clean, dry hands.
- Store them somewhere dry, and leave them in any original case or holder.
- Photograph coins exactly as they are when you ask for a valuation.
Why does cleaning lower a coin’s value?
A coin’s surface is part of what collectors pay for. Over the years, a coin develops a natural surface and color. Collectors use that surface to judge whether a coin is original and how well it has survived.
Cleaning removes or changes that surface. Even gentle rubbing can leave fine lines and an unnatural shine. Once that happens, it cannot be undone.
The major organizations agree on this. PCGS, a coin grading service, says cleaning techniques will devalue a coin. The American Numismatic Association says that, generally, a coin will lose some value after being cleaned.
What do grading services do with cleaned coins?
Grading services give coins a number on the Sheldon scale, which runs from 1 to 70. NGC, another major grading service, uses this scale. A higher number generally means better condition.
A cleaned coin may not get a number at all. PCGS says cleaned coins receive a “Genuine” designation rather than a numeric grade. NGC says harsh cleaning results in “Details” grading. NGC also notes that the value of a Details coin is never determined by grade alone.
In plain terms, cleaning can move a coin out of the normal grading system. That makes it harder for buyers to compare it with other coins, and usually less attractive to them.
Should I clean old coins before selling them?
No. This is the most common time people reach for the polish, because they want the coins to look their best. A buyer would much rather see the coin untouched.
Dirt, dark toning and old fingerprints may look unappealing to you. They do not stop a buyer from judging the coin. Cleaning, on the other hand, can turn a collectible coin into one valued mainly for its metal.
If a coin was cleaned long ago, that is fine too. Just mention it, or send photos and let the buyer assess it. Our guide What Is My British Coin Worth? explains the other factors that decide value.
What about coins that look green, black or crusty?
Leave them as they are. It is tempting to try a home remedy you found online, but many of these can do more harm than the dirt itself. A buyer can usually tell you more from a clear photo than you might expect.
If a coin seems badly affected, keep it apart from your other coins and handle it as little as possible. Then include it in your photos and description when you ask for a valuation.
Worried you might damage them?
Leave them as they are and send photos for a free, no-obligation offer in US dollars.
How should I handle old coins?
Good handling habits protect a coin’s surface. None of this needs special equipment.
- Wash and dry your hands first, so you are not adding moisture or oils.
- Hold each coin by its edges, between your thumb and finger.
- Avoid touching the faces of the coin, especially the portrait and design.
- Work over a soft surface, such as a folded towel, in case you drop one.
- Do not slide coins across a table or let them knock against each other.
How should I store old coins?
Storage does not need to be fancy. The aim is to keep coins dry, still and apart.
- Keep them in a dry place with a steady temperature, away from damp basements and bathrooms.
- Keep coins from rubbing together. A loose jar of coins causes wear every time it is moved.
- If a coin is in its original case or box, leave it there. Keep any booklet or paperwork with it.
- If a coin is in a grading holder, do not open it.
- If you need to wipe dust off a case or holder, use a soft, dry cloth on the outside only.
Grading holders are designed to protect coins. PCGS holders are tamper-evident and sonically sealed. The label shows the date, denomination, grade and a unique certification number. Breaking a coin out removes that protection and that record. See our page on selling graded British coins.
Original packaging matters for sets too. If you have Royal Mint proof sets in their cases, keep them together. Our page on selling Royal Mint proof sets has more detail.
How do I photograph coins without cleaning them?
You do not need clean coins for good photos. You need good light. NGC says lighting is probably even more important than the camera when photographing a coin.
- Use soft daylight near a window, or a desk lamp placed to one side.
- Place the coin on a plain, dark or neutral background.
- Photograph both sides, and keep the coin in focus.
- If a coin is in a case or holder, photograph it in the case or holder.
When you are ready, use our free valuation form. britishcoinsusa is a US buyer of British coins, working online and by mail across the US. We reply within 24 hours with a first offer in US dollars based on your photos. That offer is confirmed once we receive and inspect the coins. Please do not post anything until we have replied. Read how it works for the full process.
Frequently asked questions
Can I just rinse a coin under the tap?
It is best not to. Any cleaning risks changing the surface. Leave the coin as it is and let a buyer see it in its current state.
Will a buyer be able to tell if a coin has been cleaned?
Often, yes. Grading services look for signs of cleaning and grade those coins differently. It is better to be upfront about any past cleaning.
Do gold coins need cleaning?
No. Gold coins are valued partly on their gold content, but surface and condition still matter. Leave them as they are. Our page on selling gold sovereigns explains more.
I inherited coins that someone cleaned years ago. Are they still worth selling?
Yes, they can be. Cleaning usually lowers value, but it rarely removes it. Send photos for a free valuation. Our page on selling an inherited coin collection may also help.