Sending valuable coins through the mail can feel nerve-racking, especially the first time. This guide covers how to ship coins safely within the US, from packing to paperwork. The most important step comes first: wait for our reply and packing instructions before you post anything.
The short answer
- Do not post coins until we have replied with packing instructions.
- Keep coins in holders or flips, and pack them so nothing moves.
- Use a plain outer box that does not mention coins.
- Make an inventory list and take photos before sealing.
- Use insured, tracked shipping, and keep your receipt and tracking number.
When should I send my coins?
Only after we have replied. Start by sending photos and a description through our free valuation form. We reply within 24 hours with a free, no-obligation offer in US dollars.
If you would like to go ahead, we send packing instructions with our reply. Please follow those instructions, as they take priority over the general tips in this guide. Our how it works page explains each step.
The first offer is based on your photos and description. It is confirmed once we receive and inspect the coins.
How to ship coins safely: how should I pack them?
Good packing has two aims. The coins should be protected from scratches, and nothing should be able to move or rattle inside the package.
- Keep coins in their holders. Leave graded coins in their slabs, and proof sets in their original cases. Loose coins can go in individual flips or small coin holders.
- Stop movement. Group holders together, then wrap them so they cannot shift. Fill empty space in the box with padding, so nothing slides when you shake it gently.
- Use a sturdy box. A strong outer box protects the contents better than a padded envelope.
- Seal it well. Tape all the seams so the box cannot open by accident.
Please do not clean coins before sending them. Cleaning can lower a coin’s value, and we would much rather see coins exactly as they are.
What should the outside of the package look like?
Plain and ordinary. Do not write “coins”, “gold” or “silver” anywhere on the outside of the box. Avoid boxes or tape with coin or bullion branding.
The goal is a package that looks like any other parcel. A discreet box draws less attention as it travels.
What records should I keep before I seal the box?
A few minutes of record-keeping gives you peace of mind. Before sealing the package:
- Write an inventory list of every coin, set and holder in the box. Keep a copy for yourself.
- Take photos of the coins laid out together, then of the packed box before you close it.
- Photograph the sealed, labeled box.
After mailing, keep your receipt and tracking number somewhere safe. If you ever need to make an insurance claim, these records help. Our guide on How to Photograph Coins for a Valuation (Phone Camera Guide) has tips for clear photos.
Thinking of selling?
Start with photos. We reply within 24 hours with a free, no-obligation offer and packing instructions.
Which shipping service should I use for coins?
Whichever service you choose, it should be insured and tracked. Many coin owners consider USPS Registered Mail. According to USPS, Registered Mail is its most secure service.
USPS states these points about Registered Mail:
| Fact | USPS Registered Mail |
|---|---|
| Security | USPS’s most secure service |
| Tracking | Uses a system of receipts to track the item |
| Maximum insured value | $50,000 |
| How to send | Must be presented at a Post Office at the time of mailing |
Because Registered Mail must be presented at a Post Office, plan for a visit to the counter. You cannot simply drop it in a mailbox.
If you are thinking about another carrier or service, check your carrier’s rules and insurance limits for coins before you ship. Rules and limits vary, and it is worth confirming that your package is covered for its full value.
Who pays for shipping and insurance?
The seller arranges and pays for insured, tracked shipping to us, following our packing instructions. We mention this up front so there are no surprises.
Once the coins arrive, we inspect them and confirm the offer. If you decide not to sell after we receive the coins, we send them back to you. In that case, the seller pays the return postage and insurance.
What if I would rather not ship my coins at all?
That is understandable. We also offer consignment, where you keep the coins and send photos. We list the coins and look for a buyer. Our commission is 10% of the sale price, charged only if the coin sells.
Ask about consignment when you send your photos, and we can talk through which option suits you. If the coins came from a relative, see our guide to selling an inherited coin collection.
Frequently asked questions
Can I send coins before I hear back from you?
Please do not. Wait for our reply and packing instructions first. We reply within 24 hours.
Should I write “coins” on the package?
No. Use a plain outer box with no mention of coins, gold or silver.
What is the insurance limit for USPS Registered Mail?
USPS states a maximum insured value of $50,000 for Registered Mail. For other services, check your carrier’s rules and insurance limits for coins.
What happens if I decline the offer after you receive my coins?
We send the coins back. The seller pays return postage and insurance. See our FAQ for more.
Should I take graded coins out of their holders to save space?
No. Keep them in their holders. Read more about selling graded British coins.