Some coins arrive sealed in a plastic holder with a printed label. Others are loose, in an old album or in a jar. If you are comparing graded vs ungraded coins, the key question is what that holder actually tells you. This guide explains it in plain terms.
The short answer
- Grading uses the Sheldon scale, which runs from 1 to 70.
- A PCGS holder is tamper-evident and sonically sealed, with a label showing key details and a unique certification number.
- Cleaned coins may get “Genuine” (PCGS) or “Details” (NGC) instead of a straight numeric grade.
- Never break a coin out of its holder. We buy both graded and ungraded British coins.
What is the difference between graded vs ungraded coins?
A graded coin has been examined by a grading company, given a grade and sealed in a holder. An ungraded coin, often called a “raw” coin, has not been through that process.
Grading does not change the coin itself. It adds an outside opinion on the coin’s condition, sealed together with the coin. Many perfectly good coins have never been graded.
What does the number on the label mean?
Grading companies such as NGC use the Sheldon scale, which runs from 1 to 70. Higher numbers mean better condition.
The number is a shorthand for the coin’s condition. Small differences on the scale can matter to collectors. Even so, the grade is only one part of value, alongside the coin type, its metal and collector demand.
What does a PCGS holder show?
According to PCGS, its holders are tamper-evident and sonically sealed. Tamper-evident means any attempt to open the holder should be visible.
The PCGS label shows the date, denomination, grade and a unique certification number. The certification number ties that label to that coin. Keep the holder intact so those details stay meaningful.
Whichever company graded your coin, treat the holder as part of the coin. Store it flat and somewhere dry, and avoid stacking heavy items on it.
What happens to cleaned coins?
Cleaning matters a great deal to graders. PCGS says cleaning techniques will devalue a coin. It gives cleaned coins a “Genuine” designation rather than a numeric grade.
NGC uses “Details” grading for coins that have been harshly cleaned. NGC adds that the value of a Details coin is never determined by grade alone.
The American Numismatic Association says that generally a coin will lose some value after being cleaned. So if you have ungraded coins, please leave them exactly as they are.
Have graded or ungraded coins?
Send photos for a free, no-obligation offer in US dollars.
Should I ever crack a coin out of its holder?
No. Once a holder is opened, the label no longer vouches for a sealed coin. You lose the grade, the certification and the protection the holder gave.
Opening a holder can also scratch the coin. Even if you disagree with a grade, leave the holder sealed and ask us first.
The same goes for old holders that look scuffed or yellowed. A worn holder is still doing its job. Send photos and we will tell you what we see.
Is grading worth it for my coins?
Sometimes it is, and sometimes it isn’t. It depends on the coin, its condition and how collectors view that type. Grading costs money and takes time, so it is worth asking before you send coins away.
Grading may be worth considering when:
- The coin is scarce, or in unusually fine condition.
- Buyers for that type of coin usually expect to see it in a holder.
- There is a real question about whether the coin is genuine.
Grading may not be worth it when:
- The coin is valued mainly for its gold or silver content.
- The coin is heavily worn, or has been cleaned.
- There are many similar coins and little collector demand.
For example, the Royal Mint sells pre-owned sovereigns “sold solely on the basis of their gold content”. For coins like that, a grade may add little. We are happy to give a view on your coins before you spend anything.
Do you buy both graded and ungraded coins?
Yes. We buy British coins only, and we look at graded and ungraded coins alike. See our page on selling graded British coins.
For ungraded coins, photograph the front and back of each one. For graded coins, also include a clear photo of the label. NGC says lighting is probably even more important than the camera for a good coin photo.
Send your photos through our free valuation form. We reply within 24 hours with a free, no-obligation offer in US dollars. The first offer is based on your photos and description, and is confirmed once we receive and inspect the coins.
Please don’t post coins until we have replied. Read more about how it works, or see our guides to Royal Mint proof coins and branch mint sovereigns.
Frequently asked questions
Does a graded coin always sell for more?
Not always. Grade, collector demand and metal content all play a part. A holder adds information, not guaranteed value.
What does “Genuine” on a PCGS label mean?
PCGS gives cleaned coins a “Genuine” designation instead of a numeric grade.
What is an NGC Details grade?
NGC uses Details grading for harshly cleaned coins. NGC says the value of a Details coin is never determined by grade alone.
Should I get coins graded before contacting you?
Ask us first. A free valuation can help you decide whether grading makes sense.